Our Schubert: His Enduring Legacy By David Schroeder * Publisher: The Scarecrow Press, Inc. * Number Of Pages: 332 * Publication Date: 2009-08-28 * ISBN-10 / ASIN: 0810869268 * ISBN-13 / EAN: 9780810869264 Preface MUSICOLOGISTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO WRITE dispassionately about their subjects, but this does not always happen. Of course we write about the composers we select because we feel passionately about them, and I have certainly done that in the past with Haydn, Mozart, and Berg. Schubert, though, can have a mysterious effect on those who play or listen to his music, whether professionals or amateurs, taking us far beyond the normal response of excitement or love one may have for a composer’s works. For me this started when, as a teenager in the early 1960s, a novice taking singing lessons, one of the first pieces I performed publicly was Schubert’s “Standchen” from Schwanengesang. I was hooked, and it has lasted a lifetime. His appeal has not diminished at any stage of my life, and in fact, as something of a late bloomer, I could not have attempted a book about him until reaching almost twice the age he was when he died. The strongest way to embrace Schubert, as the pages that follow make clear, is by singing or playing his music, and many listeners at recitals and concerts can respond fervently because they have had some experience of playing his music and can have the listening experience transformed into something much more intimate, which comes through performance. This can be a solitary experience at the piano or a shared one with other players, and the intimacy comes from the fact that Schubert himself played his own music, sharing with his friends not only the songs and chamber music but the larger orchestral works as well. As a singer, I have had the pleasure of sharing this with many outstanding pianists, a number of them genuine Schubertians, sometimes in public performances, but most often in the privacy of a studio or a living room, just for the love of reading these wonderful songs. Some of these people need to be acknowledged in special ways, along with a few of the other Schubert fanatics I have had the good fortune to know. I have had no more willing accomplice than Bruce Vogt, starting when we were fellow undergraduates and continuing ever since. While both of us lived in England in the mid-1970s, we set out to read through all the songs, and we came fairly close to getting there. When we ran out of written transpositions for my baritone voice, we alternated between Bruce transposing at sight and me shifting octaves. Another great Schubertian is my mother-in-law, Hilda Jonas, who studied with, among others, some of the great Schubert performers of the twentieth century, including Rudolf Serkin and Artur Schnabel. We live on opposite sides of the continent, but that has not prevented us from reading Schubert lieder for hours on end at least two or three times a year since 1975. During my years in England I read with some extraordinarily fine pianists, including my fellow graduate student Roy Howat, whose marvelous performance of the Sonata in C minor (D958) in Canada I was able to arrange; Howard Ferguson, a leading chamber music performer who had just retired to Cambridge when I arrived there and was then preparing his editions of the keyboard music; Philip Radcliffe, whose playing was as sensitive as his written observations, one of which I cite in chapter 6; and an undergraduate at King’s College, Cambridge, whose name I no longer recall, with whom I read through Winterreise. On a warm summer evening while I lived in Cambridge, I once heard the accompaniment of “Liedesbotschaft” wafting across the street, and on knocking at the door to see who was playing, I met Nick Toller, with whom I then read this song and many others. On the other side of the Atlantic, in both Canada and the U.S., I have read lieder with Marlene Nepstad (with whom I gave a full recital), Mary Ann Unruh, Edward Laufer, Penelope Mark, and Michelle Fillion. My singing career has long since ended and has been replaced by reading Schubert at the piano. Being very much an amateur, I can attest to the pleasure that rank amateurs can receive, and I can say with some honesty that I do not play the piano—I play Schubert. Contents List of Photographs vii Preface ix Introduction xiii Part 1: His Lifetime 1. Speaking in the First Person 3 2. The Performer 36 3. The Good Life 74 4. Covert Opera 91 5. Songs, Symphonies, and Beethoven’s Long Shadow 112 6. Descent into Darkness 136 Part 2: His Legacy 7. Musicians 163 8. Turn-of-the-Century Vienna 189 9. Writers 216 10. Film 242 Selected Bibliography 284 Selected Discography 289 Index 293 About the Author 303
|